【3R】关于防死结界的问题……

[mimir]

我觉得到这个程度很明显都是房规了。你们都该歇一歇。
一个DM的好坏不是看他对规则有多熟，而是看他能否讲出好故事，全文完。

我倒不认为这个问题需要房规……
AND我曾经鼓吹过讨论规则，譬如说用2环法术免疫7环是否合理——不过至少在规则区，我几乎没见过这样的讨论。

[aland]

For the purposes of the death ward spell, what qualifies as a death spell or a magical death effect? I can see a few possibilities:
1) Only spells or magical effects with the [death] descriptor.
2) Any spell or magical effect which directly causes death, including a beholder's disintegration ray, the implosion spell, and the like.
3) Any spell or magical effect which results in death by a means other than hit point loss, including a maximized 10th-level fireball which necessitates a save vs. massive damage, a vampire's level drain, and the like.

The spell's text is as follows:

"The subject is immune to all death spells and magical death effects. The spell does not protect against other sorts of attacks, such as hit point loss, poison, petrification, or other effects even if they might be lethal."

Thanks for your help with this!
Daniel

Only spells with the death descriptor are death effects. Death is basically a side-effect of examples 2 and 3 from your question.

Hope that helps,

CS

你们快停.

[lega]

>>>1）Sonic Attacks (Su)和Holy Word有什么关系？
没有，为啥要有？ 又不是在讨论holy word

>>>2）Sonic Attacks (Su)中的这句描述——
Once a sonic attack has taken effect, deafening the subject or stopping its ears does not end the effect.
——和Silence有什么关系？

因为silence引用了这部分。

>>>3）即使Silence是Glamer，以下规则描述依然不会改变——
Negates sound in 20–ft. radius.
complete silence prevails in the affected area
All sound is stopped
no noise whatsoever issues from, enters, or passes through the area
特例>一般，原则

这规则当然有效，但是扩大化理解就不对了。noise和sonic的区别很明显（后者是一种能量，和会不会发出声音没有神马关系）。听不见的音波照样可以伤害你——除非这个靠的是你需要理解语言本身的内容，而并非声波本身的能量。


>>>>另外，我能不能说Glamer那所谓的——
A glamer spell changes a subject’s sensory qualities, making it look, feel, taste, smell, or sound like something else, or even seem to disappear.
——是一句无规则意义的描述性语言？

这本来就是无规则意义的，我提出来只是为了帮助你理解上面我说的那些，若是要抬杠的话自然可以无视。

[omnific9]

止められない車輪、人々を滅びの果てへ引率する…

[aland]

奥秘非你有空灌水不如去解决MTW...

[omnific9]

因为有人律师的话，姐姐我会伤心的。

[aland]

关于Silence

http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=dnd/rg/20040803a

* Sonic: Sonic is a type of energy in the D&D game, and most spells with this descriptor deal sonic damage. As you'd expect, sonic immunity makes the spell's recipient immune to sonic damage from the spell. Sonic resistance reduces sonic damage from the spell.

The silence spell description says that the spell provides protection against sonic effects. For all practical purposes, this means that a silence spell blocks line of effect for a sonic spell. The sonic spell's area cannot extend into the area that a silence spell's emanation fills, and neither can a sonic spell be cast through a silence spell's emanation to affect something on the other side.

Blasphemy
Evocation [Evil, Sonic]

你们也快停停

[lega]

挡效果线这个解释很好....X言是spread，silence是emanation，还是可以有很多可以利用。

[aland]

反正X言X不进Silence的O里面...

[lega]

但是你可以用墙把一部分人从O里挡出去...