[4e] 【目标：一或二个生物】是啥意思？？？

[所罗门]

我个人觉得这个威能参考范围攻击处理要好一些。我觉得这东西更像是群发暗影箭，虽然对于每个目标是单独的，但对于攻击者是同时发出的，至于即时打断效果，如果影响了攻击者使其无法正常攻击，我想就使整个攻击失效，如果不影响攻击者本身，那第二目标依然照常受到攻击。

虽然说这样搞逻辑上有点问题（一个头同时咬两个人），但我想处理起来会不会稍微简单一点。

[Sheepy]

樓上再讀 PHB...

MELEE ATTACK
✦ Targeted: Melee attacks target individuals. A melee attack against multiple enemies consists of separate attacks, each with its own attack roll and damage roll. Melee attacks don’t create areas of effect.

RANGED ATTACK
✦ Targeted: Ranged attacks target individuals. A ranged attack against multiple enemies consists of separate attacks, each with its own attack roll and damage roll. Ranged attacks don’t create areas of effect.
 

[所罗门]

我还是觉得这不能说明攻击就是有先后的……

[水银]

难道双打打一个人就是有先后的，打两个人就没先后？
/me 指出用双头剑同时戳俩人是很有难度的一件事..

[ethereal]

/me 指出用双头剑同时戳俩人是很有难度的一件事..

/me 指出双头剑也可以close burst..

[水银]

/me 指出扫和戳不是一回事..二次攻击起码伤害是分开投的。

[Sheepy]

我还是觉得这不能说明攻击就是有先后的……

If a monster has a power that lets it make two attack rolls ... , and the first one hits, you can use an immediate reaction before the next attack roll.

不分先後的話, 中斷就需要變成在所有攻擊完成後發生, 而不是像書上說. 當然, 這可以是 HR...

EDIT: 不過我們再看一個. PHB FAQ:

14. I am using a magical thrown weapon as part of an area of effect power.  If I am attacking multiple enemies within that area, do I need multiple weapons, or will one suffice?

    One is enough in this case.  Magical thrown weapons return to you after each attack, so you’ll be able to use it against each enemy as part of using your power.

這其實是設計師先作出的回答, 客服後來才借用的. 無論如何, 武器要等一次攻擊完了才會飛回來讓你進行下一次. 這樣會不會有先後?